We demonstrate non-immunogenic circRNA as a tool for targeted gene regulation in plants, where it acts in an isoform- and sequence-specific manner, enabling future agronomic applications. Circular RNAs (circRNAs) are single-stranded RNA molecules characterized by their covalently closed structure and are emerging as key regulators of cellular processes in mammals, including gene expression, protein function and immune responses. Recent evidence suggests that circRNAs also play significant roles in plants, influencing development, nutrition, biotic stress resistance, and abiotic stress tolerance. However, the potential of circRNAs to modulate target protein abundance in plants remains largely unexplored. In this study, we investigated the potential of designer circRNAs to modulate target protein abundance in plants using Arabidopsis protoplasts as a model system. We show that PEG-mediated transfection with a 50-nt circRNAGFP containing a 30-nt GFP-antisense sequence results in a dose- and sequence-dependent reduction of GFP reporter target protein abundance. Notably, a single-stranded open isoform of circRNAGFP had little effect on protein abundance, indicating the importance of the closed circular structure. Additionally, circRNAGFP also reduced GFP abundance in Arabidopsis mutants defective in RNA interference (RNAi), suggesting that circRNA activity is independent of the RNAi pathway. We also show that circRNA, unlike dsRNA, does not induce pattern-triggered immunity (PTI) in plants. Findings of this proof-of-principle study together are crucial first steps in understanding the potential of circRNAs as versatile tools for modulating gene expression and offer exciting prospects for their application in agronomy, particularly for enhancing crop traits through metabolic pathway manipulation.

Abstract Bidirectional communication between pathogenic microbes and their plant hosts via small RNA (sRNA)-mediated cross-kingdom RNAi (ckRNAi) is a key element for successful host colonization. Whether mutualistic fungi of the Serendipitaceae family, known for their extremely broad host range, use sRNAs to colonize plant roots is still under debate. To address this question, we developed a pipeline to validate the accumulation, translocation, and activity of fungal sRNAs in post-transcriptional silencing of Arabidopsis thaliana genes. Using stem–loop quantitative reverse transcription–PCR, we detected the expression of a specific set of Serendipita indica (Si) sRNAs, targeting host genes involved in cell wall organization, hormonal signalling regulation, immunity, and gene regulation. To confirm the gene silencing activity of these sRNAs in plant cells, SisRNAs were transiently expressed in protoplasts. Stem–loop PCR confirmed sRNA expression and accumulation, while qPCR validated post-transcriptional gene silencing of their predicted target genes. Furthermore, Arabidopsis ARGONAUTE 1 immunoprecipitation revealed the loading of fungal SisRNAs into the plant RNAi machinery, suggesting the translocation of SisRNA from the fungus into root cells. In conclusion, this study provides a blueprint for rapid selection and analysis of sRNA effectors and further supports the model of cross-kingdom communication in the Sebacinoid symbiosis.

RNA interference (RNAi) is a crucial mechanism that can contribute to immunity against infectious microbes through the action of DICER-LIKE (DCL) and ARGONAUTE (AGO) proteins. In the case of the fungal pathogen Botrytis cinerea and the oomycete Hyaloperonospora arabidopsidis, plant DCL and AGO proteins have proven roles as negative regulators of immunity, suggesting functional specialization of these proteins. To address this aspect in a broader taxonomic context, we characterized the colonization pattern of an informative set of DCL and AGO loss-of-function mutants in Arabidopsis thaliana upon infection with a panel of pathogenic microbes with different lifestyles, and a fungal mutualist. Our results revealed that AGO1 and AGO4 function as positive regulators of immunity to a bacterial and a fungal pathogen, respectively. Additionally, AGO2 and AGO10 positively modulated the colonization by a fungal mutualist. Therefore, analysing the role of RNAi across a broader range of plant-microbe interactions has identified previously unknown functions for AGO proteins. For some pathogen interactions, however, all tested mutants exhibited wild type-like infection phenotypes, suggesting that the roles of AGO and DCL proteins in these interactions may be more complex to elucidate.

Cross-kingdom RNA interference (ckRNAi), the bidirectional communication between microbes and their host counterparts, is a key element in the outcome of host colonization. Whether mutualistic fungi of the Serendipitaceae family with their broad host range use small RNA effectors (sRNAs) to colonize plant roots is still under debate. To investigate if ckRNAi is a factor in the symbiosis of Serendipita indica (Si) with Arabidopsis thaliana (Ath), we established a pipeline to validate expression, translocation and post-transcriptional gene silencing of host genes by Si-derived sRNAs (SisRNAs). First, we confirmed the expression of SisRNAs both in axenic fungal culture and during Ath root colonization using stem-loop PCR. Then, to verify the translocation of putative SisRNA effectors, an ARGONAUTE 1 immuno-purification assay (AtAGO1-IP) was employed, detecting fungal SisRNAs being loaded into the plant RNAi machinery in Si-colonised roots. Subsequently, SisRNAs and artificial sRNAs (amiRNAs), were transiently expressed in Ath protoplasts to test their gene silencing activity. Stem-loop PCR confirmed expression of sRNA effectors and qPCR validated post-transcriptional gene silencing of their predicted target genes involved in cell wall organization, hormonal signalling regulation, plant immunity and gene expression. Moreover, 5’-RLM-RACE analysis revealed amiRNA-mediated canonical cleavage in Arabidopsis targets. In conclusion, this study provides a blueprint for rapid selection and analysis of sRNA effectors in plant-microbe interactions in general and suggests cross-kingdom communication in the Sebacinoid symbiosis.

Circular RNAs (circRNAs) are single-stranded molecules that have attracted increasing attention in recent years due to their covalently closed structure and their diverse functional roles in mammalian cells, where they are involved in the regulation of gene expression and protein function. Increasing evidence suggests that circRNAs have similar functions in plants, where they play a role in plant development, resistance to biotic stress, and abiotic stress tolerance. Here, we investigated the agronomically relevant question of whether synthetic designer circRNAs can be used to modulate in a sequence-specific manner gene expression in plants. We show that treatment of GFP-expressing Arabidopsis protoplasts with designer 50 nt GFP antisense circRNA (circRNAGFP) reduces the cellular accumulation of the reporter protein in a sequence-specific and dose-dependent manner. This inhibitory activity of circRNAGFP was not abolished in various Arabidopsis ago and dcl mutants with defective RNAi pathways. Moreover, and in contrast to other types of RNA such as double-stranded (ds)RNA, circRNAs did not induce a PTI response in plant leaves. We discuss the possibility that circRNA may be applied to regulate endogenous plant genes and thus may have future potential as a novel bioherbicide.

Background Beneficial associations between plants and microbes are widespread in nature and have been studied extensively in the microbial-dominant environment of the rhizosphere. Such associations are highly advantageous for the organisms involved, benefiting soil microbes by providing them access to plant metabolites, while plant growth and development are enhanced through the promotion of nutrient uptake and/or protection against (a)biotic stresses. While the establishment and maintenance of mutualistic associations have been shown to require genetic and epigenetic reprogramming, as well as an exchange of effector molecules between microbes and plants, whether short RNAs are able to effect such changes is currently unknown. Here, we established an interaction between the model grass species Brachypodium distachyon ( Bd , Pooideae) and the beneficial fungal root endophyte Serendipita indica ( Si , syn. Piriformospora indica , Sebacinales) to elucidate RNA interference-based regulatory changes in gene expression and small (s)RNA profiles that occurred during establishment of a Sebacinalean symbiosis. Results Colonization of Bd roots with Si resulted in higher grain yield, confirming the mutualistic character of this interaction. Resequencing of the Si genome using the Oxford Nanopore technique, followed by de novo assembly yielded in 57 contigs and 9441 predicted genes, including putative members of several families involved in sRNA production. Transcriptome analysis at an early stage of the mutualistic interaction identified 2963 differentially expressed genes (DEG) in Si and 317 in Bd line 21-3. The fungal DEGs were largely associated with carbohydrate metabolism, cell wall degradation, and nutrient uptake, while plant DEGs indicated modulation of (a)biotic stress responses and defense pathways. Additionally, 10% of the upregulated fungal DEGs encode candidate protein effectors, including six DELD proteins typical for Sebacinales. Analysis of the global changes in the sRNA profiles of both associated organisms revealed several putative endogenous plant sRNAs expressed during colonization belonging to known micro (mi)RNA families involved in growth and developmental regulation. Among Bd - and Si -generated sRNAs with putative functions in the interacting organism, we identified transcripts for proteins involved in circadian clock and flowering regulation as well as immunity as potential targets of fungal sRNAs, reflecting the beneficial activity of Si . Conclusions We detected beneficial effects of Si colonization on Bd growth and development, and established a novel plant-mutualist interaction model between these organisms. Together, the changes in gene expression and identification of interaction-induced sRNAs in both organisms support sRNA-based regulation of defense responses and plant development in Bd , as well as nutrient acquisition and cell growth in Si . Our data suggests that a Sebacinalean symbiosis involves reciprocal sRNA targeting of genes during the interaction.

In filamentous fungi, gene silencing by RNA interference (RNAi) shapes many biological processes, including pathogenicity. Recently, fungal small RNAs (sRNAs) have been shown to act as effectors that disrupt gene activity in interacting plant hosts, thereby undermining their defence responses. We show here that the devastating mycotoxin-producing ascomycete Fusarium graminearum (Fg) utilizes DICER-like (DCL)-dependent sRNAs to target defence genes in two Poaceae hosts, barley (Hordeum vulgare Hv) and Brachypodium distachyon (Bd). We identified 104 Fg-sRNAs with sequence homology to host genes that were repressed during interactions of Fg and Hv, while they accumulated in plants infected by the DCL double knock-out (dKO) mutant PH1-dcl1/2. The strength of target gene expression correlated with the abundance of the corresponding Fg-sRNA. Specifically, the abundance of three tRNA-derived fragments (tRFs) targeting immunity-related Ethylene overproducer 1-like 1 (HvEOL1) and three Poaceae orthologues of Arabidopsis thaliana BRI1-associated receptor kinase 1 (HvBAK1, HvSERK2 and BdSERK2) was dependent on fungal DCL. Additionally, RNA-ligase-mediated Rapid Amplification of cDNA Ends (RLM-RACE) identified infection-specific degradation products for the three barley gene transcripts, consistent with the possibility that tRFs contribute to fungal virulence via targeted gene silencing. Significance Statement Fusarium graminearum is one of the most devastating fungal pathogens in cereals, while understanding the mechanisms of fungal pathogenesis is a prerequisite for developing efficient and environmentally friendly crop protection strategies. We show exploratory data suggesting that fungal small RNAs play a critical role in Fusarium virulence by suppressing plant immunity.

The hemibiotrophic fungus Magnaporthe oryzae (Mo) is the causative agent of rice blast and can infect aerial and root tissues of a variety of Poaceae, including the model Brachypodium distachyon (Bd). To gain insight in gene regulation processes occurring at early disease stages, we comparatively analyzed fungal and plant mRNA and sRNA expression in leaves and roots. A total of 310 Mo genes were detected consistently and differentially expressed in both leaves and roots. Contrary to Mo, only minor overlaps were observed in plant differentially expressed genes (DEGs), with 233 Bd-DEGs in infected leaves at 2 days post inoculation (DPI), compared to 4978 at 4 DPI, and 138 in infected roots. sRNA sequencing revealed a broad spectrum of Mo-sRNAs that accumulated in infected tissues, including candidates predicted to target Bd mRNAs. Conversely, we identified a subset of potential Bd-sRNAs directed against fungal cell wall components, virulence genes and transcription factors. We also show a requirement of operable RNAi genes from the DICER-like (DCL) and ARGONAUTE (AGO) families for fungal virulence. Overall, our work elucidates the extensive reprogramming of transcriptomes and sRNAs in both plant host (Bd) and fungal pathogen (Mo), further corroborating the critical role played by sRNA species in the establishment of the interaction and its outcome.

RNA interference (RNAi) is a biological process in which small RNAs regulate gene silencing at the transcriptional or posttranscriptional level. The trigger for gene silencing is double-stranded RNA generated from an endogenous genomic locus or a foreign source, such as a transgene or virus. In addition to regulating endogenous gene expression, RNAi provides the mechanistic basis for small RNA-mediated communication between plant hosts and interacting pathogenic microbes, known as cross-kingdom RNAi. Two core protein components, Argonaute (AGO) and Dicer (DCL), are central to the RNAi machinery of eukaryotes. Plants encode for several copies of AGO and DCL genes; in Arabidopsis thaliana, the AGO protein family contains 10 members, and the DCL family contains four. Little is known about the conservation and specific roles of these proteins in monocotyledonous plants, which account for the most important food staples. Here, we utilized in silico tools to investigate the structure and related functions of AGO and DCL proteins from the model grass Brachypodium distachyon. Based on the presence of characteristic domains, 16 BdAGO- and 6 BdDCL-predicted proteins were identified. Phylogenetic analysis showed that both protein families were expanded in Brachypodium as compared with Arabidopsis. For BdDCL proteins, both plant species contain a single copy of DCL1 and DCL4; however, Brachypodium contains two copies each of DCL2 and DCL3. Members of the BdAGO family were placed in all three functional clades of AGO proteins previously described in Arabidopsis. The greatest expansion occurred in the AtAGO1/5/10 clade, which contains nine BdAGOs (BdAGO5/6/7/9/10/11/12/15/16). The catalytic tetrad of the AGO P-element-induced wimpy testis domain (PIWI), which is required for endonuclease activity, is conserved in most BdAGOs, with the exception of BdAGO1, which lacks the last D/H residue. Three-dimensional modeling of BdAGO proteins using tertiary structure prediction software supported the phylogenetic classification. We also predicted a provisional interactome network for BdAGOs, their localization within the cell, and organ/tissue-specific expression. Exploring the specifics of RNAi machinery proteins in a model grass species can serve as a proxy for agronomically important cereals such as barley and wheat, where the development of RNAi-based plant protection strategies is of great interest.

Microbial pathogens secrete small RNA (sRNA) effectors into plant hosts to aid infection by silencing transcripts of immunity and signaling-related genes through RNA interference (RNAi). Similarly, sRNAs from plant hosts have been shown to contribute to plant defense against microbial pathogens by targeting transcripts involved in virulence. This phenomenon is called bidirectional RNA communication or cross kingdom RNAi (ckRNAi). How far this RNAi-mediated mechanism is evolutionarily conserved is the subject of controversial discussions. We examined the bidirectional accumulation of sRNAs in the interaction of the hemibiotrophic rice blast fungus Magnaporthe oryzae (Mo) with the grass model plant Brachypodium distachyon (Bd). By comparative deep sequencing of sRNAs and mRNAs from axenic fungal cultures and infected leaves and roots, we found a wide range of fungal sRNAs that accumulated exclusively in infected tissues. Amongst those, 20-21 nt candidate sRNA effectors were predicted in silico by selecting those Mo reads that had complementary mRNA targets in Bd. Many of those mRNAs predicted to be targeted by Mo sRNAs were differentially expressed, particularly in the necrotrophic infection phase, including gene transcripts involved in plant defense responses and signaling. Vice versa, by applying the same strategy to identify Bd sRNA effectors, we found that Bd produced sRNAs targeting a variety of fungal transcripts, encoding fungal cell wall components, virulence genes and transcription factors. Consistent with function as effectors of these Bd sRNAs, their predicted fungal targets were significantly down-regulated in the infected tissues compared to axenic cultures, and deletion mutants for some of these target genes showed heavily impaired virulence phenotypes. Overall, this study provides the first experimentally-based evidence for bidirectional ckRNAi in a grass-fungal pathosystem, paving the way for further validation of identified sRNA-target duplexes and contributing to the emerging research on naturally occurring cross-kingdom communication and its implications for agriculture on staple crops. Author Summary In the present work, we provide first experimental evidence for bidirectional RNA communication in a grass-fungal pathosystem. We deployed the monocotyledonous plant Brachypodium distachyon, which is a genetic model for the staple crops wheat and rice, to investigate the interaction-related sRNAs for their role in RNA communication. By applying a previously published bioinformatics pipeline for the detection of sRNA effectors we identified potential plant targets for fungal sRNAs and vice versa, fungal targets for plant sRNAs. Inspection of the respective targets confirmed their downregulation in infected relative to uninfected tissues and fungal axenic cultures, respectively. By focusing on potential fungal targets, we identified several genes encoding fungal cell wall components, virulence proteins and transcription factors. The deletion of those fungal targets has already been shown to produce disordered virulence phenotypes. Our findings establish the basis for further validation of identified sRNA-mRNA target duplexes and contribute to the emerging research on naturally occurring cross-kingdom communication and its implications for agriculture.